This show is sponsored by BetterHelp – Go to
This show is sponsored by Shopify – Start your free trial at
Harry Potter’s snowy owl has always been unusually intelligent — but there may be a reason for that. Today we’re diving into one of our wildest Harry Potter theories yet: that Hedwig was actually an Animagus secretly tasked with watching over Harry.
And once you start looking at the evidence — her strange behavior, her connection to Dumbledore, the Animagus registry, Nicolas and Perenelle Flamel, and the exact timing of Hedwig’s death — this theory gets WAY more convincing than it has any right to be.
#HarryPotter #WizardingWorld #SuperCarlinBrothers
🦆☕ Ducks go in cups.
Submit your own duck-in-a-cup video right here:
(Please read the rules first)
Edited by: Ethan Edghill
Written by: J & Ben Carlin
Super Carlin Brothers explore Harry Potter theories, Pixar connections, and all your favorite fandoms every week!
☕ Carlin Brothers Coffee & Merch
📲 Follow Us
Patreon ➜
Instagram ➜ &
Facebook ➜
📦 Send Us Something!
Super Carlin Brothers
PO Box 4339
Roanoke, Virginia 24015
📧 Business Inquiries Only:
carlinbrosrtp@gmail.com
🎵 Intro Music by RKVC
🎬 Animation by J. Cutt Productions
source
So what you’re saying is it’s acceptable for adults to pretend to be pets for children because this would be the second time at least
yeah that makes zero sense defnitely not a snake either
Tbf it would explain how dumbeldore seemed to always knew what was going on with the trio and just act like he doesnt 😂😂😂
But wouldnt she have died along with nicholas when dumbledore destroyed the philosophers stone
You can't prove a thing. It's an owl.
I thought I would hate this idea but it brought so much depth and love to the entire story without changing plot. Bravo!!! No notes!!!!!
What if you have to know someone's real name for it to show up like that Peter didn't show up as Peter was the name known to Harry and the name you give could show up as your name on the map it is a given true name
so none of the things you brought up in this video even come close to a strong argument. uh, okay, she's smart and a rare owl? okay.
her name means stone? that's literally not evidence of anything lol
Idk if I believe this theory but I do love it!
I thought you said "proof?" None of this is proof at all
I have a different theory that headwig could be a relative of Harry's that was a animagus or however you spell it
Dude, do not partner with BetterHelp. They are a horrible company, do some research on them.
She’s just an owl not a maladictus or animagus
Me rushing to click on the video, because there's a new carlin bros theory that i didnt know i needed badly!!!! 😮❤😂
Didn't you do a theory where you showed that she *did not actually die*, she was just out of the plot because she could not find Harry/Hermione after that?
He was an animatronic.
It looks like the book does not mattet because of film. Now when we willhave serial , i think we will find out Hagrid is Batmanin disguise.
“The map never lies!”
I think its time for us to suggest Better Help to the Brothers
A magical owl, otherwise known as, HOOdini
Doesn't mesh with your theory about why Peter doesn't show up on the Marauder's Map. But I like it.
The issue i have with the age issue and Flamel somehow deciding to die at age 665 is that the book in which we get their ages from is not a recent book. It's described as an old or ancient book. So the Flamels would have been 665 and 658 way back when that book was written. Unless you want to also argue that some (but not all) magical texts update themselves as they age.
2 minutes in, I predict that it's Regulus Black.
Edit: 5 minutes in, I'm wrong.
There are MANY known Animagus throughout J.K. Rowling's wizarding worlds not only Harry Potter. Many were registered and MANY were illegal or non-registered (Sirius Black for instance was non-registered). From all "known" Animagus from all of these stories has several birds listed but only ONE listed as a bird form, but species was not identified (Source: Pottermore Famous Wizard Cards). This was Morgan Le Fay of Aurthurian Legend. She was not a very nice witch but maybe became nice later to protect Harry from Voldemort.
665 years old… that number was from a book found in the Hogwarts library…. your saying that that book was written and put into the library that year while looking like it had been in the library for years and looked through by hundreds if not thousands of students. Unless it auto updates I would say the 665 is at least a decade out of date.
Hoo?
Kind of ties Harry and Voldy together more. In theory Harry was unable to be harmed because Hedwig an animagus/malidictus represented part of his protection, and he did eventually "die" after Hedwig was killed. Voldy was also unable to die while Nagini, a animagus/malidictus, also one of his horcruxes, was still alive, and he soon died after Nagini was destroyed. It certainly adds more depth to the parallels between the two.
Slo mo Hermoine never fails to make me laugh
Fun fact: the number of the beast 666 actually originates as a secret way for very early Christians to refer to Emperor Nero who committed purges on said very early Christians.
Is Hedwig visible on the Marauders' Map as Hedwig? When would she have time to transform to take elixirs so she doesn't die? Where would she be keeping said elixirs? Helluva coinkidinc Hagrid chose preciserly her. 665 years is kinda long for an owl, though, right? Since they don't live more than 15 – including snowy owls – and that's when well cared for in captivity. Anyway, I really like this theory.