The Captain Who LET a Torpedo Hit His Ship



In February 1917, off southwest Ireland, a rusty old collier called HMS Farnborough saw a torpedo coming and did not dodge it. She was a Q-ship: a decoy with naval guns hidden behind fake walls and flaps, built to lure German U-boats to the surface, where they liked to finish off easy targets with their deck gun instead of a costly torpedo. After eleven months without a single bite, her commander, Gordon Campbell, decided the only way to look like real prey was to really get hit.
The torpedo struck the hold. A rehearsed “panic party” rowed away in the lifeboats while the gunners lay hidden on the sinking ship. When U-83 surfaced right alongside, the White Ensign went up, the flaps dropped, and almost every one of the 45 shells hit. The U-boat sank. Campbell radioed “Q5 slowly sinking respectfully wishes you goodbye”, but the destroyer Narwhal and the sloop Buttercup towed her in and she was beached at Mill Cove. Campbell received the Victoria Cross. After the war the ship was sold and sailed as the merchant ship Hollypark until 1928.

Sources: Wikipedia, “HMS Farnborough”, “Gordon Campbell (Royal Navy officer)” (Victoria Cross citation, London Gazette), “SM U-83”, “Q-ship”; Gordon Campbell, My Mystery Ships (1928).

#history #ww1 #navy #truestory #shorts

source

34 Comments

  1. It wasn’t that they simply let it happen. They knew it was going to happen. That’s why they built ships disguised as lightly defended, outdated cargo vessels that looked like easy targets. In reality, these ships were equipped with powerful anti-aircraft and anti-ship guns, along with heavy and light machine guns to defend against torpedo boats, as well as anti-torpedo netting.

  2. It was not that they let it happen, it was they knew it would happen and made ships that looks like light easy to strike outdated cargo ships that would be able to whip our AA and AS guns and had heavy and light machine guns for anti torpedo as well netting

  3. Pretty sure American history in school teaches this the cause of why Uboats just shot down every ships they found. The germans used to surface and warn the merchant ships but since the british or americans started arming their merchant ships. So because of that Uboats started to just follow unrestricted submarine warfare.

  4. thats a war crime.
    and by the way its also the reason enemy ships will stop rendering help to drowning sailors.

    everyone looses here.

    same deal in WW2. a german u boat was rendering help after sinking a ship. broadcast intentions and flew the red cross insignia. american pilots bombed them anyways. after that every u-boat was strictly forbidden from rendering aid.

    but war crimes are only for the ones loosing the war, so all good i guess.

  5. For all the block heads in the comments claiming this is a war crime – its not. This was a Royal Navy auxiliary cruiser manned by Royal Navy sailors. Even if it wasn't, its still self defense because they were attacked first. The Germans themselves used ships like this to great effect themselves raiding allied shipping far away from home.

  6. Even if it was not a war crime at the time. Did the British ensure that the prison order was lifted? The Prisenordnung (international law of war):

    1. A submarine had to emerge over water.

    2. It stopped the enemy's merchant ship by a warning shot.

    3. The shipping documents were checked, and the crew was given time to get into the lifeboats.

    4. Only after that the ship was allowed to be sunk (usually material-friendly by stud gun)

    The use of camouflaged warships as a submarine trap ensured that on February 1, 1917, this order was revoked by order. And from then on, all merchant ships within the blockade zone around England were sunk by torpedo without warning. Thus, the British contributed to a brutalisation of the Sea War.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You might like

© 2026 Cantinho do Vídeo - WordPress Video Theme by WPEnjoy