Firing 22-pound shells at 2,700 ft/s and later arming the Tiger and Pershing tanks, Germany’s 88mm and America’s 90mm guns were nearly identical twins.
Yet while the 88 relied on hand-cranked dials and preset time fuzes, America paired its 90mm with auto-tracking radar (SCR-584), an electrical computer (M9), and a $1 billion vacuum-tube proximity fuze—quadrupling coastal V-1 kill rates to 74% in just six weeks.
#90mm #88mm #Flak88 #VTFuze #ProximityFuze #V1FlyingBomb #WWII #TigerTank #Pershing #militaryhistory #engineering #howitworks #shorts
source

━━━━━━━━━━━━
Sources · Further Reading
━━━━━━━━━━━━
■ 1. The 88 and the 90: shell weight and muzzle velocity
Wikipedia — 8.8 cm Flak 18/36/37/41
The Flak 18/36/37 fired a 20 lb (9.2 kg) shell at 2,690 ft/s (820 m/s). Effective ceiling about 26,000 ft
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/8.8_cm_Flak_18/36/37/41
Wikipedia — 90 mm gun M1/M2/M3
The M3 HE and AP rounds left the muzzle at 2,700 ft/s (820 m/s). The M71 HE projectile weighed 23.29 lb (10.56 kg)
→ Both guns fired shells of roughly 20–23 lb at about 2,700 ft/s
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/90_mm_gun_M1/M2/M3
■ 2. Reborn as tank guns: the Tiger and the Pershing
Wikipedia — 8.8 cm Flak 18/36/37/41 (same page as #1)
Krupp developed the Tiger I's 8.8 cm KwK 36 alongside the Flak 36, and the two guns shared ammunition and ballistics
Wikipedia — 90 mm gun M1/M2/M3 (same page as #1)
The M3 gun, derived from the 90mm anti-aircraft gun, armed the M36 tank destroyer and the T26 (later M26) Pershing tank
■ 3. 16,000 rounds per high-altitude bomber
Key.aero — The Eighth Air Force vs The Flakwaffe
In 1944 the 128mm flak gun averaged 3,000 rounds per aircraft shot down: half as many as the 105mm and less than one-fifth of the older 88mm models
https://www.key.aero/article/eighth-air-force-vs-flakwaffe
Hushkit — Flak: myth versus reality with Donald Nijboer
An interview drawing on Edward Westermann's "Flak: German Anti-Aircraft Defenses 1914–1945." In 1944 the 128mm needed less than one-fifth the rounds per kill of the 88mm. It also notes that flak aimed to force bombers higher and spoil their accuracy, and that aircraft damaged but not downed don't show up in these figures
https://hushkit.net/2021/03/25/flak-myth-versus-reality-with-donald-nijboer/
→ The 16,000 figure is the commonly cited 1944 average for the 88mm Flak 36 against high-flying four-engine bombers. It is higher than the war-wide average for heavy flak, which ran to a few thousand rounds
■ 4. Three of every four V-1s downed by late summer 1944
Wikipedia — Operation Diver
In the first week after the guns moved to the coast, they destroyed 17% of the flying bombs entering the gun belt. This rose to 60% by August 23 and 74% in the last week of the month, with 82% on one day. The V-1's average altitude was 2,000–3,000 ft
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Diver
Wikipedia — V-1 flying bomb
Top speed about 400 mph (640 km/h) at 2,000–3,000 ft
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/V-1_flying_bomb
■ 5. Germany's mechanical computers and radar
Wikipedia — 8.8 cm Flak 18/36/37/41 (same page as #1)
Flak batteries were usually deployed with a Kommandogerät, an analog gunnery computer, or a portable Würzburg radar
■ 6. Crews matching needles by hand
Lone Sentry — German Antiaircraft Artillery, Ch. 8 Fire Control (U.S. Military Intelligence Service, Special Series 10, 1943)
Firing data from the Kommandogerät reached receiver dials on each gun electrically, lighting up bulbs. The two gun layers and the fuze setter turned handwheels by hand to bring their mechanical pointers over the lit bulbs. Fuze time was set the same way, with the handwheel on the gun's machine fuze setter
https://wiki.lonesentry.com/manuals/german_aa/gaa8_german_antiaircraft_fire_control.html
■ 7. Preset time fuzes and over half a mile in 15 seconds
Lone Sentry — TM E9-369A German 88-mm Antiaircraft Gun Materiel, Firing Tables
The 88mm HE anti-aircraft shell (L/4.5) used the S/30 time fuze, settable up to 30 seconds
https://lonesentry.com/manuals/88mm-antiaircraft-gun/german-88-mm-firing-tables.html
→ Reaching a bomber at 23,000–26,000 ft took roughly 10 to 20 seconds. In that time a B-17 cruising near 190 mph moved more than half a mile (about 186 mph × 15 seconds ≈ 0.78 miles)
■ 8. The SCR-584 microwave radar tracked on its own
Wikipedia — SCR-584 radar
A microwave radar operating at 2,700–2,800 MHz (10–11 cm wavelength). Using conical scanning, once it locked on, it kept the antenna on the target automatically. Paired with Bell Labs' M9 gun director, it controlled four 90mm guns. With radar gun laying and the proximity fuze, the shells needed per V-1 kill dropped from 2,500 to 100
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SCR-584_radar
■ 9. The M9 electrical computer and motor-driven guns
Wikipedia — M9 gun director
An electronic analog computer built by Bell Labs that continuously calculated firing solutions for anti-aircraft guns. Its four sets of outputs laid four 90mm M1 guns automatically. From June 1944, together with the SCR-584 and proximity fuzes, it formed the backbone of the V-1 defense of southern England
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/M9_gun_director
Wikipedia — 90 mm gun M1/M2/M3 (same page as #1)
Direction and range from the SCR-584 went straight to the M9 director, which aimed the guns automatically, leaving the crews only to load
■ 10. The VT proximity fuze: a vacuum-tube radio built for 20,000 G's
Wikipedia — Proximity fuze
Anti-aircraft shells faced up to 20,000 G at launch, compared with about 100 G for rockets, and spun at close to 30,000 rpm from the rifling. New vacuum tubes had to be developed to survive this. The fuze sent out radio waves and detonated when the echo from a target showed it was close
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Proximity_fuze
■ 11. $1 billion, half the cost of the atomic bomb
Wikipedia — Proximity fuze (same page as #10)
About $1 billion bought more than 22 million fuzes. The secret was guarded at a level similar to the atomic bomb project and the D-Day invasion
Wikipedia — Manhattan Project
The Manhattan Project cost nearly $2 billion in 1945 dollars
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Manhattan_Project
■ 12. Fired only over water, for fear of duds reaching the Germans
Wikipedia — Proximity fuze (same page as #10)
At first, the fuzes were used only where the Germans could not capture them. Duds from British coastal batteries fell into the sea, out of reach. After General Eisenhower demanded their use, they were fired at ground targets in the Battle of the Bulge
Naval Gazing — The Proximity Fuze, Part 2
When the V-1 attacks began in June 1944, the ban was lifted for fire where duds would fall into the Channel
https://www.navalgazing.net/The-Proximity-Fuze-Part-2
■ 13. From radar, computer and fuze to the guided missile
Wikipedia — Project Nike
Proposed by Bell Laboratories in May 1945 as an air-defense missile. In 1953 it delivered the Nike Ajax, America's first operational anti-aircraft missile system, with a top speed of Mach 2.25. It built on experience with the analog fire-control computers of the anti-aircraft gun era
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Project_Nike
当時の工業力、新技術開発、世界最先端だったドイツ🇩🇪の技術をも凌駕するアメリカ🇺🇸、
世界一の工業力にはドイツも負けるのは必然‼️
В СССР в конце 30х сохдали ПУАЗО
the proximity fuse had more Impact on the war than the Manhattan project
The first time the Navy tested the VT proximity fuse, they gathered 10,000 shells, and two target aircraft.
The exercise was over after 3 shots.
Артиллерией по самолетам? Более тупую вещь я не слышал, вы сумасшедшие люди
88 мм это швейцарские орудия
Proximity fuses
The 88mm gun was so effective the Americans basically copied it. Hence the 90mm
vt fuse
Again, AI has the V-1' s exhaust blasting out of the back like a rocket instead of the truth…jet exhaust coming out of the thing's jet engine
Hard to believe they could build a tube-based computer, cram it into the head of a shell, and make it survive a high G launch, then MASS PRODUCE IT!!! Holy moley! Germany and Japan never stood a chance.
USA had the best artillery and anti aircraft artillery largely due to the best command and control. The proximity fuse was a game changer against aircraft.
Почему США открыли фронт только за несколько месяцев до Победы? Можно было мало жертв
Т34-85 тоже 85мм от зенитки.
Любое немецкое оружие ,периода второй мировой войны ,было лучшее…как бы это было непечально…😢😢😢
APPLES TO ORANGES!
Why cant we use a similar system against drones if it was that accurate
Piece of crap of a video full of misleadings. Germany was large England is so small on the map, the Allied had way more guns and the Germans concentrated on London. Now of course when you have so many batteries around London and all the V1 are heading there the chances of picking them up is high, also V1 didn't fly at extremly high altitudes. The Americans bombers flew at around 25k feeet altitudes which is far beyond the 88 mm range. Also, Germany way way too big and it was difficult to defend Germany from all sides unlike just London. All in all I think this is a junk video.
You didn't even count the difference in flying height.
Американцы и воцга понятия не сопостовимые, они могут только беззащитных уничтожать, от серьёзных противников они просто бегут ссыкуны😂
My Uncle was an Anti Aircraft crewman on Isle of Hoy, Orkney in defence of Scapa Flow. A Royal Navy Warship harbour. His battery got bombed, and he was in hospital full of shrapnel. They took most of it out. After 2 weeks he was sent back to his unit. He suffered all his life with pains from his wounds. In his 60's they had to operate as a piece of shrapnel was moving from his lung and nearly touching his heart due to a fall which broke some ribs. He died aged 77. He never told me his story until he'd fallen 30 feet from a gasometer gantry in early 1960's.
Not an American invention, the concept was British with a collaboration of engineering AND money by both US & UK.
Conceived in May 1940 at Christchurch, England, by British scientists William A. S. Butement, Edward S. Shire, and Amherst H. Thomson.
Because the US had the industry that was huge AND out of reach of the Axis forces, they produced the fuses.
Tell it how it actually is instead of leaving shit out to make the US look good. You blokes have a lot to do at the moment so I will leave you to fix your current problems.
The British used a 94mm gun, 32 pounder.
зенитка 88 шведская разработка.
there is ZERO chance only one out of 16k 88s found their mark yet 3/4 of the US 90s did??
Почему? Да просто потому,что американцы никогда не признают,что у кого то что то может быть лучше,чем у них…..
i would not compare usa tech to german,first this fuze shell was discovered at the end of war,and use only against japanese….90mm usa gun was an disaster gun,speed was wayyyyyy slower so…all tryed copy german flak. Didnt think why?
Автор чудак… Не 2 мм! А 2 миллиарда!
No gun or fighter, could shoot down V2 hypersonic missile
The proximity fuse design was invented and perfected at U of T university of Toronto it is a Canadian invention but was then transferred to the America to be adjusted for mass production .