Park America’s two top-scoring WWII fighters side by side, and one looks like a pencil while the other looks like a beer barrel.
Over Europe, the sleek P-51 Mustang downed 4,950 enemy planes; over the Pacific, the burly F6F Hellcat scored more than 5,000—despite being 3,400 pounds heavier and 55 mph slower.
Built to escort bombers from England to Berlin and back, the Mustang packed a narrow 12-cylinder liquid-cooled engine, a thrust-adding belly radiator, and fuel-filled laminar-flow wings to cut drag. Built for carrier warfare over open ocean, the Hellcat relied on an 18-cylinder air-cooled radial that a single bullet couldn’t stop, massive folding wings for slow deck landings, and over 200 pounds of cockpit armor.
From nose to cockpit—and even in a 1944 joint evaluation where 60 Army and Navy pilots swapped planes—here is how two opposite designs each aced the test of its own battlefield.
#P51Mustang #F6FHellcat #WWII #aviation #aerospace #engineering #warbirds #USNavy #military #howitworks #shorts
source

━━━━━━━━━━━━
Sources · Further Reading
━━━━━━━━━━━━
■ 1. Weight, speed and kill counts
Wikipedia — North American P-51 Mustang
(P-51D: gross weight 9,200 lb, top speed 437 mph. Mustang pilots
claimed 4,950 enemy aircraft in Europe, the most of any Allied fighter
there)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/North_American_P-51_Mustang
Wikipedia — Grumman F6F Hellcat
(F6F-5: gross weight 12,598 lb, top speed 391 mph. Navy and Marine
pilots claimed 5,163 kills in the Pacific, more than any other Allied
naval aircraft, at a 19:1 kill-to-loss ratio)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grumman_F6F_Hellcat
■ 2. Two engines
Wikipedia — Packard V-1650 Merlin
(A license-built Rolls-Royce Merlin: liquid-cooled V12, two banks of
six cylinders)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Packard_V-1650_Merlin
Wikipedia — Pratt & Whitney R-2800 Double Wasp
(An 18-cylinder air-cooled radial: two rings of nine cylinders)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pratt_%26_Whitney_R-2800_Double_Wasp
■ 3. The belly radiator and the Meredith effect
Wikipedia — P-51 Mustang (same page as #1)
(Coolant and oil radiators sat in one duct under the rear fuselage;
heated air leaving it produced a small amount of thrust)
Wikipedia — Meredith effect
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Meredith_effect
■ 4. The Hellcat's chunky chin
Naval Encyclopedia — Grumman F6F Hellcat
(A supercharger intake at the bottom of the cowling, with oil cooler
intakes on either side)
https://naval-encyclopedia.com/naval-aviation/ww2/us/grumman-f6f-hellcat.php
■ 5. Laminar-flow wing, wing fuel, Berlin, bubble canopy
Wikipedia — P-51 Mustang (same page as #1)
(Laminar-flow airfoils gave low drag at high speed. The P-51D
introduced the bubble canopy. Göring is quoted: "When I saw Mustangs
over Berlin, I knew the jig was up.")
Squadron/Signal — P-51D Mustang Walk Around No. 7 (1996)
(Self-sealing rubber tanks: two 92-gallon wing tanks and one 85-gallon
fuselage tank)
https://archive.org/details/p-51-mustang-2
B-17 Flying Fortress — With the Mustang over Berlin
(P-51s escorted the first major daylight raid on Berlin, March 6, 1944)
https://b17flyingfortress.de/en/?p=66
■ 6. Big folding wing, high cockpit, armor
Wikipedia — F6F Hellcat (same page as #1)
(Wing area 334 sq ft vs. the P-51D's 235 sq ft. The "Sto-Wing" outer
panels pivoted and folded back. The Navy had the cockpit mounted
higher, and 212 lb of cockpit armor was fitted)
U.S. Naval Aviation Resource Center — Hellcat Design
(The F6F was designed to take damage and bring its pilot home)
https://warbirdsresourcegroup.org/NARG/hellcat_design.html
■ 7. The October 1944 Joint Fighter Conference
Report of Joint Fighter Conference, NAS Patuxent River, 16-23 October
1944 (ed. Francis H. Dean, Schiffer, 1998)
https://schifferbooks.com/products/reportjoint-fighter-conf
U.S. Navy Aircraft History — Navy Joint Fighter Conference
(About 60 pilots, including Charles Lindbergh, flew the P-51D, F6F-5
and others, then filled out questionnaires)
https://thanlont.blogspot.com/2012/05/navy-joint-fighter-conference-october.html
ww2aircraft.net — poll results transcribed from the report
(Best fighter below 25,000 ft: F8F 30%, P-51 29%, F6F 2%. Most
comfortable cockpit: P-47 24%, F8F 18%, F6F 15%, P-51 7%)
https://ww2aircraft.net/forum/threads/report-of-joint-fighter-conference.3466/
■ 8. Notes on how the script simplifies
· "3,400 pounds lighter" compares gross weights. By empty weight, the
gap is about 1,600 lb.
· "55 miles per hour faster" uses the F6F-5's commonly cited 380 mph.
With Wikipedia's 391 mph, the gap is about 46 mph.
· Kill counts are claims.
· "One bullet couldn't kill the engine" means the radial had no coolant
to lose.
· "Even added thrust" simplifies the Meredith effect; sources differ on
how much it offset the cooling drag.
· The Berlin escorts also used the fuselage tank and drop tanks.
· "The largest on any US single-engine fighter" compares it with the
P-47 (300 sq ft) and F4U (314 sq ft).
· "Some 60 Army and Navy pilots" also included British and company test
pilots. They judged by test flights and questionnaires, not mock
dogfights.
· The Mustang's 29% was second, behind the F8F (30%). In the cockpit
category, the P-47 came first and the Hellcat third.
· Poll figures follow a forum transcription and were not checked
against the original report.
· Scenes in the video are reconstructions, not archival footage.
As always: America wins.
Now do the F-4U Corsair, which outperformed both of them, but was brutally demanding on pilots and dangerous to land on carriers, so it wasn’t as widely used as the Hellcat.
Two entirely different roles
P-51 mustang- Island defense or offense otherwise common around land
F6F hellcat- naval aviation the first f6f went on cv-10 the uss yorktown its purpose was the rival Japanese newer fighters
I still need to see a radial engine with multiple hillborn scoops for propeller fed supercharged performance
The mustang is still the most beautiful fighter ever flown.
Hellcat was battling outdated Zeros
Mustangs were up against German 109 and 190
You need to add the P51's victories in the Pacific.
Actually pretty okay ai
The F6F went into service after most of the Japanese experienced pilots had been killed. I flew against a lot of inexperienced, kamikaze pilots. These planes were comparatively easy to shoot down such as the Mariana Turkey sheet giving the F6 F. It’s reputation. Where other planes such as the F4U corsair fought more experienced pilots from the islands. The F6F was a good plane but the F4U was a superior aircraft all around.
You're comparing apples to oranges. The Mustang is a long range interceptor, designed to escort bombers deep into Germany. The Hellcat is a pursuit fighter. Built to shoot down enemy planes, period. It's built to take punishment and still make it back to the carrier. As much praise as the Zero gets, it couldn't hold a candle to the ME109 and FW 190. The Zero was very lightly built without self sealing tanks to save weight and under gunned. The US tactics sealed the deal. The Japanese preferred single combat. The US pilots were trained to stay with their wingman and never turn with a Zero. Instead, disengage and come back for another shot. The Hellcat was awesome but so were the tactics.
When the war ended, it was just scrap metal.戦争が終わるとただの鉄くず。
The Hellcat served much longer.
Id still pick SKIPPER…
Tank you 😮❤
excellent presentation
Noooo P-51's aerodynamic advantage stemmed from the streamlining effort not the airfoil. It was known the laminar flow wings had to be clean so they tried maintaining the clean surface with patties and coatings. But the airfoil itself did not contribute to the drag reduction much. Ki-44-i as an example gained 30kph from patties and sanding.
To being with, laminar wings only increase the surface that can be made laminar by about 7~10%. Commonly used airfoils can be partially laminar, especially the bottom surface. It is better to make normal wings with polished surfaces than to make an aircraft use laminar airfoil.
Its more about how they fought. The mustang qas useful to escort bombers and fight agile and fast german planes. The hellcat was built to fight the zero, a well armed, fast agile, tho poorly armored. If you build a plane like the f6f that survives and shoots incendiary at a plane that is known for catching fire easily then the f6f wins
AI slop visuals
One lands on a carrier. The other lands on a long runway. You are welcome.
The comparison of the two fighters that fought different enemies in different planes is ignorant.
Nice video, thank you.
Поставь себя со мной
A better comparison would have been a P 51 with a P47.
To be fair, Hellcat pilots were going up against barely trained pilots in near-obsolete Zero's by the end. Mustang pilots had to deal with seasoned Luftwaffe pilots in advanced planes throughout.
절케 크게 만드니 기동성이 떨어졌었지 F-4 팬텀이 ㅋ
Different tools for different jobs
They were fighting different aircraft and had different roles to play both are really great aircraft.
But the Corsair was a better plane than the hellcat. And the Corsair was faster the the mustang
Europes p51 mustang???? Huhh are we talking about the theater it was in?
OK, but a more reasonable comparison would put F6F face to face with P-47, while P-51 should go with F4U.
Mustang didn't get that bubble canopy until the D Model.
The P51 glazing needs to stop. Literally the most run of the mil late war fighter there is
The Corsair was almost as fast as the P-51 and was a far superior fighter in air to air combat. The reason the hellcat had so many kills was it was fighting mostly kamikaze pilots. Who were told not to engage. And there was more hellcats because they were the most easily used on aircraft carriers. They were also the most forgiving. While the Corsair was better at air-to-air combat it's maintenance was a pain in the ass. And it was a harder plane to fly. See what happens when you know your history
Now do Mustangs vs Corsairs. Already Corsair wins because of it's role(s) in Korea where Stang's started out but were pulled. Additionally, in Central America (I can't remember the countries)the Mustang went up against F4Us…. and were shot down. That's how you gauge a test between two of the greatest fighters of all time!
Hate to bragg but I knew this in the sixth grade.
Great vid wow, good visuals and loved the explanations i didn’t know a good bit of that